Are anxious Australian parents turning their children into schedule 'slaves'? SUSIE O'BRIEN reports
DOES your preschooler have an appointment diary for his Lego workshops?
Does your three-month-old baby attend yoga and pilates?
Does your teenager have so many after-school activities that she can barely
fit in school?
Welcome to the world of hyper-parenting, where parents wanting to maximise
their children's development submit them to a punishing routine of organised
sport and activities.
Time spent making mud pies or playing with Barbies has given way to violin
lessons, soccer practice, toddler gymnastics and accelerated learning classes.
Parents fear that if they opt out of this activity whirlwind, their kids may
never catch up.
But child development experts say an increasing number of families are
suffering burnout because of their children's gruelling daily schedules.
Psychologists also report seeing children with acute stress suffering
sleeplessness, facial tics, migraines and bed-wetting.
It's not just confined to affluent families; even those on lower incomes
save to pay for classes costing more than $20 an hour.
Alvin Rosenfeld, author of Hyper-Parenting and The Over-Scheduled Child,
says parenting has become the "most competitive adult sport".
"Today's children are so tightly scheduled that many have never invented a
backyard game or had time to just hang out with friends," he says in Youth
Studies Australia.
Mr Rosenfeld says US research suggests over-scheduling may be damaging
marriages and causing children to be diagnosed with depression and attention deficit disorder.
Lidia and Clinton Lee know the pressures facing parents all too well.
Daughter Stephanie, 9, does ballet, plays three musical instruments, takes
swimming classes and is a competition-standard gymnast.
Her appointment diary began filling up at just six months, when she began
music lessons and baby gymnastics.
BUT Mr Lee says they have no particular ambitions for Stephanie, who is in
Grade 3 at Fintona Girls' School.
"The most important thing is that she enjoys it -- and she does. She's so
enthusiastic and driven," he says.
The pressures of Stephanie's schedule weigh most heavily on Mrs Lee, who
drives from their Warrandyte home to gymnastics in Prahran three times a week.
She often spends her evenings waiting in the car for Stephanie to complete
her three-hour class.
"Stephanie loves it. She never wants to give anything up, but I spend a lot
of time in the car," Mrs Lee says.
Their son Tyler, 4, who has been diagnosed with developmental difficulties,
is also getting extra help with learning.
"Classes are not just for the high achievers but can help those at the other
end of the spectrum," Mr Lee explains.
More and more families are becoming like the Lees.
A 2003 Australian Bureau of Statistics study shows almost two thirds of
children aged 5 to 14 participate in organised sport.
Almost one third play two or more organised sports -- swimming and soccer
are most popular.
One third participate in organised cultural activities such as playing a
musical instrument, dancing or singing, and drama. Almost all receive formal
lessons.
However, children are getting some time to just chill out.
The study also reports 75 per cent of children read for pleasure, 62 per
cent ride their bike, 50 per cent do art and craft, and 98 per cent watch
television or videos.
Janet Hall, a family and relationship psychologist and author of Fear-Free
Children, says over-scheduling makes families tense.
"We are seeing a number of children whose nervous systems aren't programmed
to cope with such over-stimulation," she says.
"They are so stretched in every way, and can suffer from bed-wetting, facial
tics, migraines and even eating disorders. These are clockwork kids -- wind them
up and watch them go and go."
Playgroup Victoria program manager Kaye Plowman agrees the pressure on
families "to be always doing things, always producing things" is a concern.
"We are trying to get parents to value the simple play experiences for
children which involve both time and space," she says.
THIS pressure to perform appears to be applied to children earlier now than
ever before.
Melbourne's local parenting bible, Melbourne's Child, is packed full of
advertisements urging parents to "ensure a successful start to school" and to
give children "the educational edge".
There are Japanese language classes, Lego workshops, maths coaching, yoga,
ballet and kindermusik. Sprinkled among them are ads for anxiety disorders and
stress clinics. It's no wonder young mothers are wondering whether their
six-month-olds are missing out.
Canterbury mother Diana Dixon is already worrying about whether her
seven-month-old son, Sam, should be enrolled in swimming classes or kindergym.
"It's a concern when you hear about what some kids are already doing. You
don't want your child to miss out or be behind others," she says.
"You think, are you making the most of their potential?"
Judy Radich, national president of Early Childhood Australia, says there has
been a huge growth in such activities in recent years.
"Toddlers have to have the right shoes and the right outfit," she says. "It
's just setting kids up to be competitive from an early age.
"They have to perform in the right way. But kids can enjoy music and
movement without all this."
Providers of such classes are keen to insist their activities are fun and
appreciated by their young participants.
Learningland, for example, introduces children as young as two to letters
through craft, music, games and activities at a cost of $125 for nine lessons.
Director Cath McLeod began her business just three years ago and now has 11
centres.
"They become confident, and it's great for their self-esteem and makes them
ready to take that step into prep," she says.
"We are not there to push them or hothouse them."
Another in-demand educator is Sue Keogh, who runs Babygym for babies from
three months old.
At $95 for 10 weeks, babies and their carers learn massage, basic stretching
and exercises designed to aid digestion and relaxation.
"I'm anti-flashcards," she insists. "This is about the benefits of gentle
interaction. Nobody needs to do these things."
VICTORIAN Parenting Centre director Warren McCann says a lot of structured
activities are in fact good for children but are not necessary for development.
"It's understandable that parents want the best for their children, but
children will still learn to walk and run and jump even if they don't attend
gymnastics," he says.
Even those running children's activities call for moderation.
Gay Hopgood, Victorian Yamaha Music Education Centre senior administrator,
says parents can be "suckered into taking their kids out every afternoon and
every Saturday morning".
But she insists music lessons -- as early as age three -- build crucial oral
skills, stimulate the imagination and aid storytelling.
So what can parents do to keep things under control?
Mr McCann says the time to stop is when parents and children "feel under
stress by the logistics of their timetable".
Ms Radich suggests reading to children daily and encouraging unstructured
play time and experimentation with music and dance.
"Most important is establishing your relationship with them. Kids have their
whole lives to be bossed around by adults," she says.
STEPHANIE'S SCHEDULE
Monday
Ballet, one hour
Tuesday
Rhythmic gymnastics, three hours
Mitiamo string quartet
Wednesday
Swimming, half an hour
Thursday
Night off
Friday
Gymnastics, three hours
Saturday
Gymnastics, three hours